Strawberry Short Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Spread the frosting thick. Press the cookie crumbles down hard. Refrigerate until it all sets and holds. That’s it. That’s strawberry shortcake.

Why You’ll Love This Strawberry Cake

No actual baking skills required. The brownie base is basically thick batter that doesn’t care if you’re perfect. Cream cheese frosting stays creamy even cold. Doesn’t get rock-hard like buttercream. Tastes like something you didn’t make in 2 hours. Golden Oreos stay crunchy instead of getting soft and sad. The strawberry gelatin mixed in actually tastes like strawberries. Not fake. Not overpowering. Refrigerate it. Comes out better the next day, which basically never happens with dessert. No fancy equipment. No stand mixer required. You can do this with a bowl and a spoon if you’re desperate.

What You Need for Strawberry Shortcake

Melted butter — 4 tablespoons total. Some goes in the batter, the rest binds the crumbles later. Keeps things moist.

Eggs. Two. They’re what makes the base hold together instead of being a wet puddle.

Strawberry cake mix. One cup. Not vanilla. Not yellow. Strawberry. The flavor has to come from somewhere and this is it.

Strawberry gelatin. Three tablespoons total — two go in the batter for moisture and tang, one goes in the crumbles for flavor. Powder form. The stuff you’d use for Jell-O but you’re not making Jell-O.

Cream cheese. Six ounces. Room temperature. This is the frosting base. Cold cream cheese won’t whip right. Let it sit out.

Unsalted butter. Three tablespoons, soft. Mixed with the cream cheese for texture. Salted butter will throw off everything.

Vanilla extract. One teaspoon. You need it.

Powdered sugar. One cup. This sweetens the frosting and makes it stiff enough to hold shape.

Heavy cream. Two tablespoons. This is what makes the cream cheese frosting actually whip up instead of staying dense.

Golden Oreos. Twenty of them. The vanilla ones. Not regular Oreos. Not the triple-stuffed. The golden ones have that subtle sweetness that works here.

How to Make Strawberry Shortcake

Heat your oven to 345 degrees. Line an 8x8 glass dish with parchment paper. Spray the paper lightly — and this matters — or the edges stick and you’ll be picking brownie bits off the sides for a week.

Melt the butter. Whisk it with the eggs in a medium bowl. It’ll look slick and broken at first. That’s fine. Fold in the strawberry cake mix and two tablespoons of the strawberry gelatin until it thickens. You want thick batter. Paste consistency. Dense. Stop folding before you think you’re done. Overmix and the texture gets mealy and weird.

Pour it into the baking dish using a rubber spatula. Spread it out. Press gently. If you press too hard you crush the air pockets and it comes out dense and wrong. Too light and you get holes. Medium pressure. You’ll feel it.

Bake for 23 to 28 minutes. Watch the top. When cracks start showing and a toothpick comes out with moist crumbs still stuck to it — not wet batter, just crumbs — it’s done. The edges should be this golden pink color. Pull it out. Let it cool on a wire rack. Completely cool. Warm frosting on warm cake is a disaster.

How to Get Strawberry Shortcake Frosting Right

Beat the cream cheese and soft butter together in a large bowl. Don’t overheat it or the butter gets greasy. You want them combined but still cool. Add vanilla. Pour the powdered sugar in slowly — not all at once or you’ll cloud yourself in powder — and beat on high speed until it gets fluffy. Then add the heavy cream and keep whipping. It should get thick and fluffy and hold a shape but still spread easy. If it’s too soft, throw the whole thing in the fridge for 10 minutes. Frosting is what holds this together. Get it right.

Spread it all over the cooled brownie base. Generously. Don’t be stingy. The base needs to be completely cool or the frosting slides off and breaks apart.

Strawberry Shortcake Assembly and Crust Topping

Put the Golden Oreos in a food processor. Pulse them. Short bursts. You want chunks. Big ones. Dust is useless. You’re looking for actual crunch, actual texture.

In a bowl, mix that one remaining tablespoon of strawberry gelatin with the cookie chunks. Drizzle two tablespoons of melted butter over everything. Pulse a few more times or just stir with a spoon. The butter sticks the gelatin and crumbs together without making it wet mush. It should look moist and chunky. Buttery. Gleaming.

Spread this over the frosted brownie layer. Press down. Not light. Press down so it actually anchors into the frosting and doesn’t slide off when you cut it. Cutting cold cake is already risky. The topping falling off makes it worse.

Refrigerate for at least an hour and a half. Longer is fine. Overnight is actually better. The layers set. Everything firms up. The flavor gets deeper somehow.

Cut with a hot knife. Dip it in hot water, wipe it off, cut one line. Repeat for each cut. Hot knife beats a cold knife every time for clean edges.

Strawberry Short Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

By Emma

Prep:

35 min

Cook:

28 min

Total:

2h 10min

Servings:

16 servings

Ingredients

• 4 tablespoons melted butter, divided
• 2 large eggs
• 1 cup strawberry cake mix
• 3 tablespoons strawberry gelatin, divided
• 6 ounces cream cheese, softened
• 3 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 cup powdered sugar
• 2 tablespoons heavy cream
• 20 Golden Oreo cookies

Method

1. 1 Preheat oven to 345°F. Line 8x8 glass dish with parchment, spray lightly with non-stick spray. Don’t skip spray or edges stick.
2. 2 Whisk melted butter and eggs in medium bowl. Fold in strawberry cake mix plus 2 tablespoons strawberry gelatin until thick batter forms. Think paste. Resist urge to overmix. Batter resistant and dense means right.
3. 3 Using rubber spatula, spread batter evenly in baking dish. Press gently, not too much or air pockets vanish. Bake 23-28 minutes until top shows cracks and toothpick comes out with moist crumbs. Edges golden pink. Cool on wire rack, barely warm is okay.
4. 4 In large bowl, beat cream cheese and softened butter till combined but not melted. Add vanilla. Slowly add powdered sugar, beat high speed. Pour heavy cream. Whip till thick, fluffy, holds shape but spreads easy. If too soft, chill briefly. Frosting is final creamy glue.
5. 5 Spread frosting generously over cooled brownie base. Not wet or hot, else frosting melts.
6. 6 Break Golden Oreos in food processor. Pulse short bursts till chunks remain. Must not pulverize to dust. Clumps lend crunch and texture.
7. 7 Mix remaining 1 tablespoon strawberry gelatin with cookie crumbles in bowl. Drizzle 2 tablespoons melted butter over mixture. Pulse few times till moist but chunkiness intact. Butter binds crumbs without soggy mush. Mix till crumbs gleam and sprinkle sticks.
8. 8 Layer crumb topping evenly over frosted brownies. Press down gently but firmly into frosting to anchor topping. Pressing key; topping should hold without sliding off when cut.
9. 9 Refrigerate at least 1.5 hours to set layers. Serve cold or near room temp. Cut clean with hot knife to avoid smeared layers.
10. 10 If cake mix scarce, sub with vanilla or white cake mix. Reduce gelatin if too tart. Cream cheese can swap mascarpone or Greek yogurt for tang. Butter partly replaceable with coconut oil, but flavor changes.
11. 11 Visual cues rule over minutes. Thick batter resists spreading; frosting pipes well; crumbs sticky but chunky; golden edges on bake signify doneness. Listen to crackling top, smell rich strawberry aroma. Avoid overbaking or dry edges ruin chew.

Nutritional information

Calories

345

Protein

5g

Carbs

41g

Fat

19g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions About Strawberry Shortcake

Can you use regular cake mix instead of strawberry? Yeah. Vanilla works fine. White cake works. You’ll lose the strawberry flavor though — it’s all coming from the gelatin. If you go vanilla cake, use vanilla gelatin or just skip it and add a tablespoon of strawberry extract to the frosting instead. Haven’t tried that exact combo but it should work.

What if the frosting is too soft? Refrigerate it for 10 minutes. It’ll set up. If it’s still slouching after that, you used too much heavy cream or your cream cheese was too warm. Next time use less cream or chill the cream cheese longer before you start. It happens.

Does this need to stay refrigerated? Yes. The cream cheese frosting will sit at room temperature for like an hour and be fine. More than that and it gets soft and slides around. Keep it cold.

Can you substitute the cream cheese frosting? Mascarpone works. So does Greek yogurt but you lose creaminess. Both taste tangier. Philadelphia cream cheese specifically is good here — the texture is smoother than store brands. Doesn’t really matter though as long as it’s cream cheese.

How long does strawberry shortcake keep? Three days in the fridge covered. After that the cake starts to absorb moisture and gets dense. The frosting stays fine but the texture of the base gets off. It’s still edible, just not as good. Eat it within three days.

Can you make this without gelatin? Not really. The gelatin gives it flavor and texture. Skip it and you have a chocolate — well, brown — cake with cream cheese frosting. That’s fine but it’s not strawberry shortcake anymore. You need the gelatin.