Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies with Cadbury Eggs

Cadbury eggs melting into warm chocolate chip cookies. That’s it. That’s the whole thing. Made these last Easter when someone brought a bag of the little cream eggs and I was like, why are we not putting these in cookies? Cut them up, fold them in, 23 minutes later you’ve got gooey pockets of caramel and chocolate in every bite. Sheet pan means no fussing with individual cookies. Just press and bake.

Why You’ll Love This

Hits the Easter table looking homemade but tastes like you actually planned this. Takes 38 minutes total — 15 prep, 23 in the oven, done before anyone gets hungry.

Chocolate cookies that aren’t trying to be fancy. Semi-sweet chips plus the Cadbury eggs do the work. Brown sugar and melted butter make them rich without being heavy. The caramel inside is the whole point.

One pan. No cooling racks. No spacing cookies out. Spread the batter, slide it in, slice it up. Less cleanup, more eating. Holiday baking without the stress.

Easter Sheet Pan Chocolate Cookies with Hidden Caramel

Unsalted butter — 7 tablespoons, melted. Don’t let it brown. Granulated sugar and packed light brown sugar. The brown sugar matters. Fresh stuff, not the hard brick from the back of the pantry. Whole eggs plus two extra yolks. More yolk means richness. Whole milk and vanilla extract.

Flour, baking powder, salt. Just the basics. Semi-sweet chocolate chips — a full cup. Cadbury cream eggs chopped into chunks. That’s the secret. Not smooth. Not powdered. Chunks. Big enough that you hit them when you bite. Flaky sea salt for the top if you want it. Optional but worth it.

Chopping, Prepping, Getting to the Oven

Cadbury eggs in a ziplock bag. Seal it tight. Rolling pin. Two firm whacks. Maybe three. The bag keeps it contained. Tried chopping on a board once. Sticky mess everywhere. The bag method works every time.

Preheat to 320°F. Standard half sheet pan — 13 by 18 inches. Spray it with nonstick spray. Parchment’s not needed. The batter spreads and releases fine.

Melt the butter while the oven heats. Still warm, not bubbling. Pour it into a large bowl with both sugars. Whisk hard. Break up the brown sugar lumps. This takes a minute but it matters. Lumpy brown sugar makes uneven texture throughout.

Crack the whole eggs and the two yolks right in. Add milk and vanilla. Whisk until smooth. No streaks. Not runny. Just uniform.

Sift the flour with baking powder and salt. Fold it into the wet stuff gently. Don’t overwork it. The batter gets thick. Almost doughy. It should be pliable but not spreadable yet.

Fold in the Cadbury chunks and chocolate chips. A cup of each. Maybe more if you’re feeling it. This is where the chocolate cookies stop being regular and start being the thing people actually want.

Spoon the batter onto the prepared pan. Press and spread it toward the edges. Don’t panic. It’ll settle. It’ll spread in the oven. You can scatter extra candy and chips on top before baking if you want glossy melty hits across the surface. Or add them after. Both work.

Baking, Cooling, Getting the Timing Right

Bake for 18 to 23 minutes. Watch it. Oven temps vary dramatically. Edges should go golden to faint tan. The center looks soft. Actually squishy when you jiggle the pan gently. The cookie’s set but not firm. Not dry. That’s the target.

If it puffs up too much, tap the pan gently to settle it. Let it cool completely on the pan. Carryover cooking firms up the centers while it sits. Sprinkle flaky sea salt on top if you’re using it. The salt hits different with the caramel and chocolate.

Cool it fully before slicing. Cut into 24 squares. Straight lines. The edges get crispy. The centers stay chewy. You’ll hit pockets of caramel and chocolate in almost every piece.

Mistakes You’ll Make and How to Skip Them

Don’t use white sugar where brown sugar goes. The brown sugar brings moisture and flavor. White sugar alone makes them drier. Doesn’t sound like much but it changes everything.

Overworking the dough after flour hits makes them tough. Fold gently. Stop as soon as flour disappears. The batter should be thick but still soft.

Undercooking looks scary but it’s fine. Soft centers set as they cool. Overbaking makes them crispy throughout. If they seem done at 18 minutes, pull them out. If they still jiggle in the very center at 23, that’s exactly right. The carry-over heat does the rest.

Using frozen Cadbury eggs works but they take longer to chunk cleanly. Thaw them first. Thirty minutes on the counter. Makes chopping so much easier.

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies with Cadbury Eggs

By Emma

Prep:

15 min

Cook:

23 min

Total:

38 min

Servings:

24 servings

Ingredients

• 7 tablespoons unsalted butter melted
• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 3/4 cup packed light brown sugar
• 2 whole large eggs
• 2 egg yolks
• 1/4 cup whole milk
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 teaspoon baking powder
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1 cup chopped chopped Cadbury cream eggs (see tip)
• 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
• Optional: flaky sea salt for topping

Method

1. Cadbury egg chopping tip
2. 1 Place the cream eggs in a ziplock bag. Seal tightly. Take a rolling pin, give a couple firm whacks. No mess, nice chunky bits perfect for pockets of goo. Tried hacking on board? Sticky nightmare, trust me.
3. Preheat and prep pan
4. 2 Crank oven to 320 F. Standard half sheet pan, 13x18 inches. Spray with nonstick spray. No parchment needed here, batter sticks but also spreads and releases nicely.
5. Melt, whisk, sugar time
6. 3 Melt butter first so it’s warm but not bubbling. Dump sugars in large bowl, add melted butter. Whisk, whisk, whisk. Break lumps from brown sugar. Soft fresh brown sugar helps; stale clumps make uneven texture.
7. Wet stuff in
8. 4 Drop in whole eggs plus extra yolks, milk, vanilla. Whisk until uniform. Smooth consistency but not runny. Eggs bring moisture and richness.
9. Dry ingredients next
10. 5 Sift flour with baking powder and salt. Fold into wet, gently but no overmixing. Batter will be thick, almost doughy but pliable.
11. Chocolate explosion
12. 6 Fold in chopped Cadbury egg bits and chocolate chips. At least a cup each. The charm lies in those hidden pockets of melty candy and chocolate. Batter thick and chunky now, just right.
13. Spread & top
14. 7 Spoon out onto prepared pan. Press and spread evenly to edges. Don’t freak, it will settle and spread in bake. Top with extra candy and chips –scatter before baking or after for melty glossy hits.
15. Into the oven
16. 8 Bake 18-23 min but watch attentively. Edges golden to faint tan, center still looks soft and squishy when jiggle gently. Cookie set but not firm, not dry. Oven temps vary dramatically so handle like a detective.
17. Cool & finish
18. 9 Tap the pan gently if puffed too much to settle. Let rest completely on pan, carryover cooking firm up centers. Sprinkle flaky sea salt if desired. Cool fully before slicing into 24 squares. Enjoy the gooey bursts.

Nutritional information

Calories

220

Protein

3g

Carbs

30g

Fat

10g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use regular chocolate chip cookies as a base instead? No. The ratio’s different. The moisture’s different. Extra yolks and melted butter make these specific. Just make these.

What if my Cadbury eggs are frozen or too hard to chop? Leave them on the counter for 30 minutes. Softens just enough. Rolling pin in the bag still works but thawed goes faster.

Should I bake this on a convection or regular setting? Regular convection dries things out. Regular setting, 320°F. Give it time. Don’t rush the temp up.

Can I make these chocolate chip cookies ahead? Bake them, let them cool completely, keep them in an airtight container. Three or four days. They get chewier as they sit. Not a bad thing.

What’s the difference between this and making chocolate chip cookies normally? The Cadbury eggs. The extra yolks. The brown sugar ratio. Also the sheet pan format. Spreads differently. Bakes more evenly. Less individual fussing.

Why the flaky sea salt on top? Cuts the sweetness. Makes the caramel taste more like caramel. Chocolate gets deeper. It’s subtle but once you’ve tried it salted, unsalted feels flat.