Cheesecake Almond Cookies with Candied Cherry

Spray the scoop. Dough sticks otherwise. Three batches minimum, and you’ll want to do it right the first time because re-scooping warm dough loses half the lift. These aren’t tricky—they’re just cream cheese cookies that want a thumbprint pressed in the middle while they’re still warm enough to hold it. Powdered sugar icing goes in that well. Candied cherry on top. That’s the whole thing.

Why You’ll Love This Cheesecake Almond Cookies Recipe

Takes 35 minutes start to finish. Oven time alone is 15 minutes, so you’re looking at 20 minutes of actual work. Not nothing. Faster than most.

Tastes like the comfort food version of something fancy. Cream cheese in the dough is what does it—butter alone gets you a generic sugar cookie. This one’s dense, a little tangy, has something going on.

Homemade almond cookies hit different when you use actual almond extract instead of guessing. One teaspoon. That’s all. The flavor builds as they cool, tastes better the next day.

Works as a snack, a light dessert, or something to hand someone. No frosting to melt on your hands. Icing in the thumbprint stays contained. Cold ones are good. Room temp ones better.

Store them and they keep. Refrigerate if you want to stretch a week. Won’t go stale fast like dry almond cookies do.

What You Need for Homemade Almond Cookies

All-purpose flour. Two and a half cups. Don’t substitute cake flour—won’t hold the shape right.

Baking powder. A teaspoon and a quarter. Gives lift but not too much. These shouldn’t puff into clouds.

Salt. A quarter teaspoon. Sounds small. Changes everything about the taste.

Cream cheese. Eight ounces, and it’s gotta be soft before you start. Cold cream cheese won’t incorporate. Leave it on the counter 30 minutes if it just came from the fridge.

Unsalted butter. Half a cup. Salted works if that’s what’s there, but unsalted lets you control salt yourself.

Sugar. One cup of granulated. Brown sugar would darken them too much. Stick with white.

Almond extract. One teaspoon. Not almond flavoring, not almond oil—extract. The real thing tastes sharp until it bakes, then rounds out into something almost buttery.

Eggs. Two large ones. Temperature doesn’t matter as much as most recipes say it does. Cold eggs just take 30 more seconds to mix in.

Cooking spray. Any kind. Makes the scoop not stick. Saves about five minutes of frustration.

Powdered sugar icing. Mix powdered sugar with a bit of milk or water until it’s thick but pourable. Not listed in the ingredient amounts because you make it while cookies cool.

Candied cherries. Red or a mix. They’re the topping. Could use sprinkles. Won’t look as good though.

How to Make Cheesecake Almond Cookies

Heat the oven to 350 degrees first. Let it sit while you prep. Line a sheet with parchment—not foil, not bare metal. Parchment. Edges stick to foil and the bottoms get ruined.

Whisk the flour, baking powder, and salt in a bowl. Just a whisk, not a sifter. You’re not making pastry. This takes maybe 30 seconds. Mix until you can’t see any streaks of baking powder. That’s it.

Grab the cream cheese and butter—both gotta be soft—and beat them together. Use a hand mixer if that’s what you have. A stand mixer with a paddle is easier. Go for two minutes. It should look light and fluffy. If you see chunks of cream cheese, keep beating. Cold spots means cold dough, which means flat cookies.

Pour in the sugar. Not all at once. Add it in a few batches. Keep beating for another minute after each addition. The sugar dissolves and creates little air pockets. That’s what gives the cookie that slight crackle on top later.

Add the almond extract. Then add the eggs one at a time. Beat after each one for maybe 30 seconds. Don’t go crazy here—overmixed eggs make the dough tough. You want the yolk for richness but the white for some lift. Balance it.

Now fold in the flour mixture. Gradually. Use a spatula. Stop when you can barely see streaks of flour still visible. A few flour specks left is better than mixing too much. The dough should be thick and sticky. Not wet, but not dry either. Scoopable.

How to Get Cheesecake Almond Cookies Soft with Perfect Thumbprints

Spray the cookie scoop. Actually spray it. Just a quick hit of cooking spray. Scoop a heaping tablespoon onto a baking sheet. Space them two inches apart. They don’t spread much but they need room.

Spray the scoop again between batches. Dough sticks like glue to a dry scoop. It’s faster than trying to scrape it off.

Bake for 13 to 16 minutes. Not 12. Not 20. Look for edges that are firm but pale. The tops should look kind of crackled, not smooth. When you touch the top gently, it bounces back a little. That’s the signal.

Pull them out. While they’re still warm—and this matters—press your thumb into the center of each one. Or use the back of a small spoon. Press hard enough to make a well but not hard enough to go all the way through. You’re not making a volcano. Just a thumbprint. A dish for icing.

Wait five minutes on the baking sheet. Don’t move them yet. They’re still setting but getting firm enough to handle.

Transfer to a wire rack. Let them cool completely. If you ice them while they’re warm, the powdered sugar melts into nothing.

Cheesecake Almond Cookies Tips and Common Mistakes

Don’t skip the cooling step. Warm cookies can’t hold icing. They’ll just drink it and get soggy.

Icing goes in the well once the cookies are cold. Mix powdered sugar with a tablespoon of milk or water. Spoon it in carefully. Not a lot. A teaspoon worth, maybe less. Too much and it runs off the sides and makes a mess.

Candied cherry goes on the icing while the icing’s still tacky. If you wait until it dries, the cherry just sits on top and rolls off later. Press it in gently.

Almond extract is strong. One teaspoon is enough. Don’t double it thinking more is better. The flavor intensifies as they bake.

Storage is easy. Airtight container. Room temperature if you’ll eat them in a day or two. Refrigerate if you’re stretching it longer. The cream cheese icing won’t spoil fast but it’s better cold anyway.

Baking time varies by oven. 13 minutes in a fast oven. 16 in a slow one. Watch them, not a timer. Pale edges and crackled tops—that’s when they’re done.

Overmixing the dough makes them tough. Underbaking makes them collapse when they cool. Overbaking makes them dry. There’s a narrow window. It’s not hard to hit, just pay attention.

Cheesecake Almond Cookies with Candied Cherry

By Emma

Prep:

20 min

Cook:

15 min

Total:

35 min

Servings:

30 servings

Ingredients

• 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 1/4 teaspoons baking powder
• 1/4 teaspoon salt
• 8 ounces cream cheese softened
• 1/2 cup unsalted butter softened
• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 1 teaspoon almond extract
• 2 large eggs
• cooking spray
• powdered sugar icing
• candied cherries for topping

Method

1. 1 Preheat oven to 350°F. Line baking sheet with parchment paper. Always parchment; forget foil here — edges stick and ruin bottoms.
2. 2 Whisk together flour, baking powder, and salt vigorously. No lumps. Sets the stage for cookies that hold shape but don’t toughen. Resist grabbing coarse sift. Just fine whisk.
3. 3 In mixer bowl, paddle attachment preferred but hand mixer fine, cream softened cream cheese and butter. Go until that light fluff, no grit of cold chunks hiding. Smooth base is critical.
4. 4 Add sugar in chunks, keep beating 1-2 minutes. Don’t skimp — sugar dissolves and aerates dough, it’s subtle but matter.
5. 5 Mix in almond extract and eggs slowly. I suggest one egg at a time; Yolks bring richness, whites keep bounce. Overmixing eggs here will bake rubber bands non-stop.
6. 6 Add flour mixture gradually. Fold just to combine; a few streaks left better than tough chew. Dough should be thick, sticky but scoopable.
7. 7 Spray a 1 1/2 tablespoon scoop with cooking spray, scoop heaping mounds onto sheet 2 inches apart. Spray scoop between batches or dough sticks like glue. No scrape with fingers or will soften dough velocity loss.
8. 8 Bake 13-16 minutes; edges firm, pale, no brown. Crackled tops and gentle bounce under finger. Oven times vary — trust these cues. Underbake, cookies collapse; overbake, crumbly.
9. 9 Out of oven, immediately press thumb or back 1/4 teaspoon into each cookie forming well. Press firmly but don’t punch through. Gives a dish for icing. Wait 5 minutes on sheet to start setting; still warm but handle them gently.
10. 10 Transfer to wire rack to finish cooling. Cold cookies keep structure for icing application; warm ones melt it.
11. 11 Fill wells with powdered sugar icing spooned carefully. Dollop small, not flooding sides. Add candied cherry while icing tacky, gently press. If icing sets before cherry, they slide or sink.
12. 12 Store airtight once fully cooled. Refrigerate if cream cheese and icing linger a few days. Improvised twists? Swap almond for vanilla, lemon zest if feeling bold. Cream cheese can be Neufchâtel for lower fat, keeps texture dense but works fine.

Nutritional information

Calories

120

Protein

2g

Carbs

15g

Fat

6g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions About Cream Cheese Cookies

Can I make these without almond extract? Yeah. Swap it for vanilla. One teaspoon vanilla extract. Won’t taste like almond cookies anymore but they’ll still be good. Different thing entirely though.

How long do these keep? Three days room temperature, airtight container. A week in the fridge. The cream cheese icing handles cold better than heat, so don’t leave them on the counter in summer.

Can I use Neufchâtel instead of cream cheese? Works fine. It’s got less fat. The cookies get denser. Still taste good. Texture shifts but not in a bad way.

What if my icing won’t stick to the candied cherry? It’s too dry. Add a tiny bit more milk to the icing. Just a few drops. Needs to be tacky, not set. Apply the cherry while the icing’s still wet enough to grab it.

Do I really need a cookie scoop? No. A spoon works. Scoop just makes them all the same size so they bake evenly. If you use a spoon, they’ll bake at different rates. Some done, some not. Cookie scoop is five bucks and saves headaches.

Can I freeze these? Yes. Cool them completely. Stack with parchment between layers. Freezer bag. They’ll last a month. Thaw on the counter. Don’t microwave or the icing gets weird.