Buttermilk Herb Vinaigrette with Fresh Dill

Buttermilk and Greek yogurt go in a bowl first — not fancy, just mixed until it loosens up. Three ingredients in and you’ve already got something worth tasting.

Why You’ll Love This Buttermilk Salad Dressing

Takes 15 minutes total. Mix, taste, done. Healthier than bottled stuff because you control what goes in — no weird stabilizers or fillers that sit in your fridge for months. Works on literally any salad. Greens, grain bowls, roasted vegetables. Even cold rice if you’re being weird about it. Vegetarian and tastes like something, not like a diet compromise. Lasts two days in the fridge, which means you can make it once and actually use it more than once before it goes bad.

Buttermilk Herb Vinaigrette with Scallions and Chives

Buttermilk. Cold. The base. Greek yogurt — about half as much as the buttermilk. Makes it creamy but not thick like ranch. One large scallion, sliced thin. The white and green parts both. Apple cider vinegar. Not white vinegar. Too sharp. Cider’s softer. A teaspoon of maple syrup. Sounds weird. Trust it. One small garlic clove, minced fine. Not a big one. Small matters here. Fresh dill and fresh chives. Not dried. Dried tastes like nothing. A teaspoon of each, chopped. Salt and pepper at the end — you’ll taste as you go anyway.

How to Make a Creamy Maple Vinaigrette

Start with the buttermilk and yogurt in a bowl. Whisk it until it’s smooth and pourable — not whipped, just even. Takes maybe a minute.

Add the scallion and garlic right after. Stir it around so the green stuff is spread out, not clumped. The smell hits different once the garlic’s in there — sharp but not mean.

Pour the vinegar in slowly. Then drizzle the maple syrup over. Don’t rush this part. Swirl it with a spoon or fork — you’re not trying to whip air into it, you’re just mixing.

Fold the dill and chives in at the very end. Fold, not stir. Big difference. Stirring smashes the herbs up and they disappear. Folding keeps them visible and fresh-tasting.

How to Get the Apple Cider Vinegar Vinaigrette Balanced and Right

Taste it now. Before you do anything else. The vinegar should cut through the creamy stuff, make your mouth water a bit. Not pucker, just — sharp enough that you know it’s there.

If it’s too thick for your greens, add more buttermilk. A splash. Mix and taste again. Too thin? Let it sit for 10 minutes and it’ll thicken slightly as the herbs release water.

Salt comes last. Add a pinch, taste, add a tiny bit more if needed. Pepper goes in right before you use it — freshly cracked, not ground. The texture matters more than you think.

Let it sit at room temperature for 5 to 10 minutes before you use it. Watch for tiny bubbles forming around the herbs. That’s the flavors actually talking to each other. Not a big deal if you don’t see them. Just means you’re in a hurry.

Greek Yogurt Dressing Tips and Mistakes to Avoid

Don’t overthink it. This is five minutes of actual work, maximum.

Temperature matters. Cold dressing on cold greens tastes better. Warm greens make it taste flat. Refrigerate it if you made it ahead.

White vinegar doesn’t work. Already tried it. Too aggressive. Cider vinegar is smoother.

The herbs have to be fresh. Dried dill tastes like straw. Dried chives taste like dust. Just don’t.

Garlic — use less if you’re nervous. A small clove is actually small. One normal clove makes it aggressive.

If you added too much salt, add more buttermilk. No way to fix it except dilute it. Similar story if the vinegar’s too sharp — milk mellows it out.

Keeps for 48 hours in a covered container. After that the herbs start turning brown and it tastes a bit flat. Stir it again before you use it. The herbs settle to the bottom.

Buttermilk Herb Vinaigrette with Fresh Dill

By Emma

Prep:

15 min

Cook:

0 min

Total:

15 min

Servings:

4 servings

Ingredients

• 90 ml buttermilk
• 45 ml Greek yogurt
• 1 large scallion, thinly sliced
• 30 ml apple cider vinegar
• 7 ml maple syrup
• A small clove garlic, minced finely
• 5 ml fresh dill, chopped
• 5 ml fresh chives, snipped
• Salt and cracked black pepper to taste

Method

1. 1 Start by gently mixing buttermilk and Greek yogurt in a bowl until just combined, creamy but still fluid.
2. 2 Add the sliced scallions along with minced garlic, stir to distribute evenly; aromas begin to lift here, sharp and fresh.
3. 3 Pour in the apple cider vinegar and drizzle the maple syrup over, swirl slowly. Vinegar sharpness should cut through the richness, balance is key.
4. 4 Toss in chopped dill and chives, fold in gently avoiding over stirring that smashes herbs.
5. 5 Season with salt and freshly cracked black pepper. Taste repeatedly; seasoning evolves as ingredients mingle.
6. 6 Let sit 5-10 minutes at room temperature. Observe small bubbles forming around herbs—sign of flavors marrying.
7. 7 Adjust thickness if needed by adding a splash more buttermilk or thinning with cold water for pouring ease.
8. 8 Use immediately or refrigerate covered up to 48 hours. Stir again before serving, herbs may settle.
9. 9 Common hiccup: too thick? Thin with milk or lemon juice to reintroduce brightness and loosen texture.
10. 10 Substitutions: sour cream for Greek yogurt for heavier body, white balsamic vinegar if cider vinegar unavailable. Maple can swap with agave or rice syrup for different sweet notes.

Nutritional information

Calories

60

Protein

2g

Carbs

5g

Fat

3g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions About Buttermilk Herb Vinaigrette

Can you use sour cream instead of Greek yogurt? Yeah. It’ll be heavier, richer. Less tangy because sour cream’s thicker. Works fine if that’s what you have.

What if you don’t have fresh dill? Different dressing. Dried dill tastes wrong. Don’t bother. Use parsley or basil instead if you need something green.

How long does it actually keep? Two days covered in the fridge. After that it starts tasting like old yogurt. Herbs get brown. Use it sooner if you can.

Can you make it without the maple syrup? It’s only a teaspoon. Skip it if you want. The dressing gets sharper, less balanced. Agave works too. So does a tiny bit of honey.

Will this work on hot salads or warm greens? Cold is better. Heat breaks the yogurt down and it gets thin and weird. Make it, chill it, use it on cold stuff.

Can you double the recipe? Yeah. Same ratios work. Keep the garlic at one small clove though — more garlic doesn’t mean better. Everything else scales fine.