Creamy Blue Cheese Penne with Toasted Walnuts

Listen for the sizzle when the wine hits the pan. That’s when you know it’s working. This penne pasta with blue cheese is the kind of thing that looks like you spent actual time on it but takes maybe 30 minutes total — and most of that is just boiling water and waiting around.

Why You’ll Love This Blue Cheese Walnut Penne

Comes together in half an hour. Literally just one pot after the pasta goes in. Tastes expensive. Gorgonzola and aged pecorino romano make it taste like something you’d order somewhere, but the ingredients cost less than takeout. Works as actual comfort food — creamy, salty, warm, done. Not a health kick situation. Cold leftovers the next day are almost better. Flavors settle. Cream thickens up. Might be better than fresh, honestly. Vegetarian and nobody notices.

What You Need for Penne With Gorgonzola and Walnuts

Penne. 425 grams. Short pasta holds the sauce better than long stuff. One medium shallot minced fine. Not white onion. Shallots are sweeter, less aggressive. Two cloves garlic. Finely chopped. Bigger pieces get bitter. Olive oil. 40 ml. Cheap olive oil works fine here — the cream covers everything anyway. Dry white wine. 150 ml. Not cooking wine. The actual stuff you’d drink. Matters more than people think. Heavy cream. 150 ml. The percentage doesn’t matter that much. Just get the thickest one you see. Gorgonzola. 100 grams. Cut into cubes. Melts faster that way. Toasted pecan pieces. 200 ml. Buy them already toasted. Toasting them yourself adds ten minutes and you’ll burn them. Not worth it. Aged pecorino romano. 125 ml grated. Sharp. Not the young stuff. The sharp one has texture and bite. Fresh chives. 50 ml chopped. Parsley works. Chives are better. Salt and pepper. You know how much.

How to Make Blue Cheese Penne With Cream Sauce

Large pot. Fill it with water. Salt it till it tastes like the ocean — not kidding. Bring it to an actual rolling boil where you can see the bubbles getting aggressive.

Toss the penne in. Stir immediately. Like right away. Starch’s a thing and it sticks if you don’t move it around. Cook it till it’s firm but tender — bite a piece at the 10-minute mark. If it snaps, keep going. If it bends, it’s close. 11, 12 minutes usually. Drain it. Don’t rinse. Toss it with a tiny drizzle of olive oil so it doesn’t cement itself into a brick.

Same pot now — clean it out or just leave the residual oil, doesn’t matter much. Warm the 40 ml olive oil till it shimmers. Not smoking. Shimmering is the target. Toss the shallot in. Stir gently. Watch it go from white and sharp to kind of translucent and soft. Maybe 3 minutes. Add the garlic. Stir for like 30 seconds until you smell it. That’s it. Longer and it gets bitter. Bitter ruins everything. Season lightly with salt and pepper right now — flavors stick better when it’s early.

Pour the white wine in. You’ll hear it pop and sizzle. That sound is good. Stir it around. Lower the heat a notch. Let it simmer till the liquid’s almost gone — you’ll see it coat the pan bottom. One minute, maybe two. You want the wine reduced, not evaporated. Acidity matters but not if it overpowers everything.

Pour the cream in slow. Stir constantly. Lower the heat again — gentle heat from here on out. Drop the gorgonzola cubes in slowly, stirring the whole time. Watch it melt. It’ll go from chunky to smooth if you don’t rush it. Too high heat and the fat breaks — the sauce separates into greasy streaks and watery bits. Low heat, patience, stir constantly. It’ll melt right.

Add the pasta back in. Fold it gently into the sauce. Don’t stir like you’re angry. Gentle coating. Toss the pecans in. Let it warm through for 3 or 4 minutes. Watch the sauce thicken and cling to the noodles. Taste it. Fix the salt and pepper now. Stir the chives in last — 30 seconds before plating. Heat kills fresh chives. You want them bright.

Tips for Getting This Creamy Penne With Shallots and Garlic Perfect

Sauce too thin? Simmer it longer, stir constantly. The cream thickens as it reduces. Give it another minute or two.

Sauce too thick? Splash in more cream. Or wine. Your call. Cream is safer — wine adds acidity which might tip the balance.

Missing something in the flavor department? Squeeze of lemon juice. Or splash more wine after the cream melts. Acid wakes everything up.

Gorgonzola sometimes has a sharp, almost metallic edge. That’s normal. The cream balances it out. If it still bothers you, use less gorgonzola, add more pecorino instead.

The pecans — you can toast them ahead of time in a dry pan. Watch for the nutty smell, not the burnt smell. Those happen like two seconds apart. Or just use them as-is if you bought the pre-toasted kind.

White wine choice matters more than people think. Sauvignon Blanc works. Pinot Grigio works. Anything dry and not too floral. Sweet wine makes the sauce taste wrong.

Don’t skip the pasta water before draining. Just a little olive oil keeps it loose. Pasta drying out in the pan is its own problem.

Creamy Blue Cheese Penne with Toasted Walnuts

By Emma

Prep:

10 min

Cook:

20 min

Total:

30 min

Servings:

4 servings

Ingredients

• 425 g penne or other short pasta
• 1 medium shallot minced
• 2 cloves garlic finely chopped
• 40 ml olive oil
• 150 ml dry white wine
• 150 ml heavy cream 15–35 %
• 100 g gorgonzola cubes
• 200 ml toasted pecan pieces
• 125 ml grated aged pecorino romano
• 50 ml fresh chives chopped
• Salt and pepper

Method

1. 1 Boil large pot salted. Watch for pasta swelling and surface bubbles — toss in penne. Stir immediately to avoid stickiness. Cook till firm but tender, about 10–12 minutes, bite test your ally. Drain, toss with small drizzle of oil, stir to coat. Keeps pasta loose while awaiting sauce.
2. 2 Clean same pot, warm olive oil until shimmering but not smoking. Toss shallots in. Stir gently; soft translucence signals readiness. Add garlic, stir carefully, just until aroma rises. Overcooked? Bitter. Season lightly with salt and pepper now.
3. 3 Splash white wine. Listen for pop and sizzle as it hits the hot pan. Stir, reduce heat a little. Simmer to near dryness; watch liquid coat the pan bottom. One minute tops to avoid overpowering acidity.
4. 4 Pour cream in, stir steadily. Lower heat. Toss in gorgonzola cubes slowly, stir until melted but not grainy. Melt process delicate; too fierce heat breaks fats — cream breaks, sauce separates. Adjust heat accordingly.
5. 5 Add drained pasta back in. Fold gently, coating. Toss in pecans. Warm through 3–4 minutes. Watch for sauce thickening, clinging to noodles. Final taste check; balance salt and pepper. Chives last — stir in just before plating, preserve fresh brightness.
6. 6 Serve with generous sprinkle of pecorino. Garnish handful extra chives if you’re feeling extra herbal punch.
7. 7 Common fix: sauce too thin? Let simmer a bit longer, stir frequently. Sauce too thick? Splash more cream or white wine. Missing acidity? Add squeeze lemon juice or splash more wine after cream melts. Nuts can be toasted ahead or quick dry pan — watch for nutty aroma, not burnt.

Nutritional information

Calories

470

Protein

16g

Carbs

38g

Fat

28g

Print Recipe Save to Pinterest

Frequently Asked Questions About Blue Cheese Walnut Pasta

Can I use walnuts instead of pecans? Yeah. Walnuts work. They’re a bit earthier, less buttery. Same amount.

How long does this keep? Three days in the fridge easy. Tastes better on day two, honestly. Reheat gently on the stove with a splash of cream if it’s too thick.

What if I don’t have gorgonzola? Blue cheese works. So does Roquefort. Any blue-style cheese that crumbles melts fine. Flavor changes but it works.

Is this actually vegetarian? Yes. No meat anywhere. Pecorino and gorgonzola are usually vegetarian but check the label if you’re strict about it.

Can I make this ahead? Don’t make it ahead. Make the sauce ahead, sure. Store it separately. Combine with hot pasta right before eating. Pasta gets mushy if it sits in sauce.

What wine should I use for penne with gorgonzola sauce? Dry white wine. Sauvignon Blanc is ideal. Pinot Grigio works. Don’t use anything sweet. Don’t use cooking wine. Actually drink it first to know what you’re putting in.

Should I toast the walnuts myself? Buy them pre-toasted. Saves time. Toasting them yourself adds steps and you’ll probably burn them. Not worth the 10 minutes.